Former ‘American Idol’ contestant and part‑time pastor Michael J. Andrews was arrested on Feb. 19 in Austin, Texas, and charged with the murder of his wife, 38‑year‑old Sarah Andrews, whose body was discovered in a home office after a neighbor reported a foul odor.
Background
Andrews rose to national attention in 2015 when he auditioned for the show’s fourteenth season, earning praise for his soulful performances. After the show, he returned to his hometown and began serving as a youth leader at the First Hope Community Church, where church members described him as “very talented” and “dedicated.” In early 2026, friends reported tension in the couple’s marriage, but no police reports were filed. On Feb. 18, a neighbor noticed a strong chemical smell emanating from the Andrews residence and called 911. Police entered the home with a warrant and found Sarah Andrews unresponsive, later confirmed dead by medical examiner.
The Charges
The Travis County District Attorney’s Office, in coordination with the FBI and the Texas Rangers, filed a charging document alleging that Michael Andrews “intentionally caused the death of Sarah Andrews by means of a lethal injection of a controlled substance.” He is charged with one count of capital murder, a Class A felony under Texas law, and is being held without bail pending a preliminary hearing. The indictment also lists a lesser count of tampering with evidence. Prosecutors have not yet released details about the weapon or substances alleged to have been used.
Key Takeaways
- Michael Andrews, a former ‘American Idol’ contestant, is now accused of murdering his wife in Texas.
- The victim, Sarah Andrews, was found dead in the couple’s home after a neighbor’s tip led police to the scene.
- Prosecutors allege the homicide involved a lethal injection, and Andrews faces a capital murder charge.
- The case involves multiple agencies, including the FBI, Texas Rangers, and Travis County DA’s Office.
What's Next
A preliminary hearing is scheduled for March 15 in Dallas County District Court, where a judge will determine whether the case proceeds to trial. If the capital murder charge is upheld, Andrews could face the death penalty or life imprisonment without parole. Defense attorneys have filed a motion to suppress certain forensic evidence, citing potential Fourth Amendment violations. The investigation remains ongoing, and authorities have indicated that additional charges could be considered if further evidence emerges.